
Player Analysis 101: How to analyse a player
In the famous words of Italy manager Roberto Mancini, “There are 60 million people in Italy… and 60 million coaches.” Everyone has an opinion on how a player performed. Some even hold their opinions so strongly that they declare players “rubbish” or “not good enough” after watching just a few games.
Don’t get me wrong, a player could well be rubbish and not good enough. But how do you know? In this article, we’ll break down the basics of player analysis and evaluation and give you the tools you need to make more accurate judgements about players. It could be match analysis or something broader, but the method remains the same.
How NOT to evaluate or analyse a player
Before we talk about how to do it, let’s first discuss how not to do it.
Making strong judgements about a player after watching a single game, or even a handful of games, is far from advisable. You cannot get an accurate idea of a player’s ability from just a few matches.
Why? The player could simply be in bad form.
If you watched Erling Haaland between December 2025 and January 2026, for example, you might have gotten the impression that he was an average striker rather than one of the best forwards in world football.
The other thing? Don’t use a single metric to judge a player’s ability in a particular area. If you place too much emphasis on one metric, you’re likely to miss something else that is more important.
This doesn’t apply to every metric, but it applies to more than 95% of them.
What do you need to judge a player fairly?
1. Context
I know, you’ve heard the word too many times from people trying to defend poor performances. However, you cannot overemphasise the importance of context.
This is because you cannot fairly evaluate players without considering their circumstances. Football is a team sport, so most events that happen on the pitch are the result of a collection of factors. You need to understand what those factors are – or at least enough of them to make a fair assessment.
For example, if a centre-back always seems to be making errors, before you conclude that he is error-prone, find out whether he is making those errors because he is the player who is usually best positioned to deal with the opposition’s threat.
Sometimes, a centre-back’s partner is so poor positionally that the bulk of the defensive actions – both good and bad – fall on one player.
In this scenario, the argument isn’t that the centre-back isn’t making errors. The question is whether those errors are natural consequences of circumstances beyond the player’s control.
This is why context is so important. Evaluate players in light of their circumstances.
And no, it’s not making excuses. Making excuses is making excuses. Applying the right context is giving yourself the best chance of reaching an accurate evaluation.
2. Know what statistics tell you – and what they don’t
There are thousands of statistics collected by data sites, and no one person can keep track of all of them.
Statistics, however, tell you what happened, but not necessarily why it happened. If you don’t understand this, you’re likely to read something into the data that isn’t actually there.
This point ties into the first one, because every statistic has context surrounding it.
Let’s use a relatable example. When comparing two goalkeepers, using the number of goals conceded alone will lead to a flawed evaluation. Goals conceded have as much to do with the goalkeeper’s ability as they do with the team he plays for and the number of shots he faces.
A goalkeeper may actually be poor, but you cannot reach that conclusion using just one metric.
3. Tactical systems and styles
For a long time, many people didn’t realise how heavily some player statistics are influenced by the system they play in.
Sterling is a good example. At Man City, the 31-year-old played in a team that took a large number of shots, partly because of its style of play and the quality of its chance creators.

Now, playing for Man City does not guarantee that you will score lots of goals, because your finishing ability still matters. However, the volume of goals a player produces can be influenced by factors beyond the player’s individual skill.
This also applies to other metrics, especially for defenders and midfielders.
A centre-back’s interception numbers, for example, are likely to be much lower if he plays for a possession-heavy side. Why? He simply doesn’t have as many opportunities to intercept the ball, considering that an interception can only happen when your team doesn’t have possession.
Pass volume is another metric heavily influenced by a manager’s tactical style. Long-ball accuracy is one of the few passing metrics that is more directly connected to the player’s own ability.
What this means is that you cannot evaluate two centre-backs who played in completely different tactical systems in the same way.
The volume of defensive actions will favour the side that spent more time defending. Progressive passes will favour the team that had much more of the ball.
Things to consider when evaluating centre-backs
You want to look at duels and long-ball accuracy. If it’s a match analysis, look at how comfortable the whole team was in possession.
More importantly, look at the performance of the central midfielders. If the midfielders perform poorly, the centre-backs are likely to suffer. Look at the roles the centre-backs played in the goals conceded while also considering their overall performance.
For example, if a player makes an error that leads to the goal that costs his team the game, you can criticise him for the mistake while acknowledging that he had a good overall performance.
Mistakes happen, and it is bad practice to base an entire verdict on the mistakes that occurred during a match.
What to consider when evaluating midfielders
Check defensive actions in the context of the tactical style the manager deployed. Measure each midfielder’s performance against his partner, if he had one.
Was he left on an island to do all the defensive work? If he was, you should be more forgiving in your evaluation.
If the team had a substantial amount of possession, check how effective the midfielder was at progressing the ball.
When checking ground and aerial duels, take the volume into account. Should the volume be higher? Should the success percentage be higher based on his physical profile and previous numbers?
These questions help you understand whether the numbers actually tell the full story.
What to consider when evaluating attacking midfielders
This one is particularly tricky. One major thing to check is whether the player has creative freedom. Then check how often they are on the ball.
Obviously, you need to measure this against the team’s overall possession average. If the whole team averages 41% possession, for example, a creative midfielder on that team will naturally have fewer opportunities to make a meaningful impact.
With attacking midfielders, you should check chance creation and big-chance creation numbers. Also look at passes into the final third and penalty area.
The goal is to understand not just what the player created, but how often the team’s tactical setup gave them the opportunity to create.
What to consider when evaluating strikers
Check what the team’s chance creation looks like. Strikers cannot create every goalscoring chance for themselves. A forward playing in a team with poor chance creation is almost always going to struggle.
Check big-chance conversion. If a player is converting around 50% of a very small number of big chances, you can expect that percentage to drop when he starts getting significantly more opportunities.
If the striker plays for a side that consistently dominates shots, check his shot volume. Does he lead the team in shots? If he doesn’t, there may be a reason.
You should also consider where those shots come from. A striker taking fewer shots but consistently getting into high-quality positions is much less useful for a team than one taking a large number of low-quality attempts. Usually, a larger number of shots is a mixture of low quality and high quality shots. However, more shots is always preferable to fewer shots.
The foundation of player analysis
This article doesn’t cover everything you need to fairly evaluate players, but it covers the foundation. I did mention “basics” at the start of the piece.
You can now look through the noise on matchdays and have a better idea of which players actually performed well, instead of simply going with who fans believe had a rubbish outing.
Understand these basics, and you’ll start seeing things that other fans – and even some analysts – don’t.
Latest Posts
- Why Joao Pedro’s injury has become a problem for Chelsea
- Why Brajan Gruda, not Florian Wirtz, is Germany’s next big talent
- Joey Veerman is the spice Netherlands has needed for years
- Player Profile Analysis: Who is the ideal Premier League footballer? PART 2
- Player Profile Analysis: Who is the ideal Premier League footballer?

Pingback: Why Brajan Gruda, not Florian Wirtz, is Germany's next big talent