Premier League

Man Utd: The board is now responsible for this mess, not Carrick

Manchester United is now in the relegation zone going into the second international break of the season. In fact, by the time the Red Devils face Liverpool later this month, it would be the first time they face the Reds from the relegation zone since the 1930s.

Obviously, Michael Carrick is still at the helm and is very clearly out of ideas, but he stopped being responsible for this mess after the 0-3 Bournemouth loss.

At that point, those making the decisions at the club should have pulled the plug on the Carrick project. This was especially important given the performances of the disgraced Ruben Amorim at AC Milan.

Everyone — and their cousin — knew Carrick was finished at Manchester United

The players, fans, coaching staff and even the ball boys knew that the 45-year-old’s time at Old Trafford was done. Even Carrick himself knew.

And no, it wasn’t just about the Bournemouth game. From the start of the season, it was clear that whatever Carrick had going for him during the 2025/26 season was no longer there.

This season, Manchester United has won just one game. The win came in August. It’s a lot worse than just one win in 10, though. You see, the Red Devils have only scored 14 goals but have conceded 19, and these goals aren’t down to poor goalkeeping either. The team is simply poor both in and out of possession.

Before Bournemouth, Carrick was to blame. Now, it’s the board

Since the Bournemouth loss, the board has become responsible for the state of Manchester United. Keeping Carrick in the job when the players knew he was a dead man walking was ill-advised.

Manchester United manager Michael Carrick

Exposing him to press conferences was little more than a humiliation ritual, especially when the person asking the questions knows that the manager being interviewed is as good as gone.

We’ve seen the rumours of managers being linked with the job. The club hierarchy is clearly working on Carrick’s replacement, but it seems too reluctant to make the decision necessary to stop the rut.

Removing Carrick is more important for the squad at the moment than the arrival of a new manager. The earlier the former Manchester United midfielder is removed, the earlier the squad can be refreshed with new ideas.

Keeping him in the dugout while the club searches for his replacement will only mean Carrick’s men continue to slip down the table.

Why things can still get worse

The Red Devils are in 18th place but are just one point above Crystal Palace in 20th. This means Manchester United could well be bottom by the time the next round of fixtures is played.

The club’s owners need to act now if they want to have any hope of salvaging this season.

At this point, the question is no longer whether Carrick should be sacked. The board has had enough evidence to make that decision. No, the question is how much worse Manchester United’s season will get if they continue to wait.

Latest Posts

Olaoluwa Nwobodo

A seasoned football writer and editor. Lover of the beautiful game, and an impeccable track record for player predictions and analysis. Independent contributor for FanSided for over 7 years. SEO expert.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *