Premier League

Player Profile Analysis: Who is the ideal Premier League footballer?

There’s an ongoing narrative that the Premier League is the hardest league to play in. Fans who have watched the league for decades see England’s top flight as a humbler of players.

You cannot blame these people, either. Many players have succeeded in other leagues only to struggle in England’s premier competition.

Speaking about the intensity of the Premier League, former Chelsea chairman Todd Boehly once famously said:

“There’s no bigger sport in the world. When you think about just the size and scale of European football, it’s mind-numbing and there’s no better league in the world than the Premier League. If you look at how these guys play, the speed with which they play the game.”

He then used former Chelsea defender Kalidou Koulibaly as an example, saying:

“In Serie A, I get to think and then run but in the Premier League, I have to run while I think.”

In this article, we’re talking about who the ideal Premier League player is. We’ll look into what kind of player you can expect to thrive in the Premier League. To do that, we first need to understand the league.

What makes the Premier League unique?

Two things make the league particularly special.

For one, the money clubs have allows them to afford some of the best talent football has to offer. That includes both playing and coaching talent.

One natural consequence of this is the variety of tactical systems players are exposed to. If you’re a player in a Premier League team, you need a robust skill set, especially if you’re going to play for one of the Big Six sides.

This is because you need to be effective against several tactical shapes and styles.

Another consequence of this financial power is that the Premier League accommodates a wide variety of player profiles. This is important for this piece because it means there isn’t just one type of player who can thrive in the league.

The second thing that makes the Premier League unique is its intensity.

England’s top flight has a reputation for being a league where “anyone can beat anyone”. Obviously, this is a universal football truth, but it is demonstrated more blatantly in this league.

The difference between the top six and the mid-table teams in the league, while clear, is usually smaller than in other major leagues.

What counts as success in the Premier League?

To further understand the ideal Premier League player, we have to measure players against outcomes. Different teams need players for different reasons. Some need to win the league, while others simply need to remain in it. These expectations factor into the kind of player you need.

This is where temperament comes in. Success is what every club wants, but success looks different from club to club. A team that has hovered around the top six and wants to challenge for the title needs players who can raise the level of everyone around them.

A player who has played the same role successfully elsewhere can do it in the Premier League too — in the right circumstances.

What is the ideal Premier League centre-back?

Let’s start with the defence.

The Premier League has plenty of physical centre-backs, so to compete, you must be able to hold your own physically. In England’s top flight, a centre-back must meet a certain threshold for aerial duels, ground duels and passing.

For aerial duels, a centre-back needs to average between 60% and 65%. Anything over 70% is considered elite, but you don’t need to be elite in this area to succeed. Virgil van Dijk has consistently ranked among the best in aerial duels in this league, and in some seasons he has gone as high as 80%.

Liverpool captain Virgil van Dijk

Most competent centre-backs stay within this range. 

Aerial prowess tends to improve for very young centre-backs but remains relatively stable from around the age of 25 onwards. This means age is important when evaluating centre-backs.

If a 19-year-old is winning 61% of his aerial duels, he could potentially be closer to 66% or 70% by the time he reaches 25.

Aerial-duel discussions, however, would be incomplete without addressing the elephant in the room: height.

Very few centre-backs shorter than 1.88m hit 70% in aerial duels. James Tarkowski is a great example. He consistently reaches the 70% range despite being 1.85m tall. Aerial prowess is a combination of excellent timing and jumping ability, so shorter centre-backs can post high numbers. It is simply rare.

For ground duels, centre-backs need to average a 55% to 64% win rate. Higher figures put you in the elite class, but again, you only need to be competent; you don’t need to be elite.

Unlike aerial duels, success here doesn’t depend as heavily on physical attributes such as height and weight. Ground duels are more about reading the game and anticipating the behaviour of the ball and the opponent.

The next aspect to consider is passing.

The trick here is that the passing requirement varies depending on the team you play for. One clear metric that separates centre-backs in this area is long passing. The best passing centre-backs can often be recognised through their long-passing ability.

In the Premier League, you need to be around 43% to 50% in long-passing accuracy. This is because most centre-backs won’t play for high-possession teams. On lower-possession sides, you won’t have as much space or time to pick out long passes. Anything over 52% is considered very good, while anything over 55% is elite.

Long-passing statistics tend to remain relatively stable for established players and can therefore be a useful measure of passing ability. Teams and tactical styles play a role, but success in this area is not entirely dependent on them.

Now, let’s talk about interceptions.

Due to the areas of the pitch centre-backs control, they are well placed to intercept passes into opposition strikers and forwards. This makes their reading of the game an essential part of the evaluation.

In this league, possession-heavy teams need their centre-backs to average between 0.9 and 1.1 interceptions per 90 minutes. For teams that have much less of the ball, you need them in the 1.4 to 1.8 per 90 range.

Keep in mind that interception and tackling numbers are heavily influenced by tactical styles.

Who is the ideal Premier League central midfielder?

The numbers look slightly different for central midfielders.

There are four main areas you need to examine when testing a midfielder’s readiness for the Premier League. The first is passing accuracy.

Central midfielders are often tasked with controlling the game, recycling possession and starting attacks. This means their pass selection becomes important, and for central midfielders, passing accuracy can be a reflection of that selection.

This is why you need your central midfielders to average between 85% and 90% passing accuracy, regardless of their long-ball accuracy.

Speaking of long balls, central midfielders usually do better, on average, than centre-backs. Hence, you need your midfielder to average at least 50% to 62% accuracy. This is a key test of their passing ability. Starting attacks, beating pressing traps and switching play are all tasks that fall on midfielders, and all require long ball competency.

Many long balls land in the midfield area, so you also need someone with a 46% to 57% aerial-duel win rate.

For ground duels, you want them in the 50% to 59% win-rate range.

In part 2, we’d finish up with numbers you need to take note of when analyzing strikers, and goalkeepers. Stay tuned.

Latest Posts

Olaoluwa Nwobodo

A seasoned football writer and editor. Lover of the beautiful game, and an impeccable track record for player predictions and analysis. Independent contributor for FanSided for over 7 years. SEO expert.

One thought on “Player Profile Analysis: Who is the ideal Premier League footballer?”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *